Couple missing since Sunday found dead below Aspen’s Capitol Peak Tuesday, 3rd and 4th death on mountain in 2017 |

Couple missing since Sunday found dead below Aspen’s Capitol Peak Tuesday, 3rd and 4th death on mountain in 2017

Jason Auslander/The Aspen Times
The 14,130-foot Capitol Peak is located about 14 miles west of Aspen in the Elk Mountains.
Anna Stonehouse/Aspen Times

The bodies of an Aspen couple missing since Sunday were found Tuesday afternoon at the base of the north face of Capitol Peak, an official said.

A helicopter search crew spotted the bodies of Ryan Marcil and Carlin Brightwell about 2:25 p.m. Tuesday, said Jesse Steindler, a commander with the Pitkin County Sheriff’s Office. The two were recovered from the mountain and arrived at the airport just before 6 p.m., he said.

“Given where the bodies were found, it is probable they fell off somewhere near (Capitol’s summit),” Steindler said. “Generally speaking, they were found below the summit.”

The couple, who were in their mid- to late-20s, had been dating for about six or seven months, were in love and had moved in together, friends said Tuesday.

Brightwell worked at Aspen Emporium and Flying Circus on Main Street for about two years and Marcil was working in Aspen for his family’s Florida-based business, friends said. He also served on the board of Aspen Strong, a local mental health advocacy group.

Families of the victims were arriving in Aspen on Tuesday evening, Steindler said.

The deaths are the third and fourth this summer on the treacherous 14,130-foot peak located west of Aspen.

Numerous reports about the missing couple, who friends said hiked to a high camp Saturday afternoon and planned to climb the peak Sunday, were posted on Facebook and on Tuesday. Some speculated that they might have camped an extra night to witness Monday’s solar eclipse.

“Because the plans were somewhat tentative and there was no confirmed medical emergency, it was decided that the urgency to initiate a search was not great,” according to a Sheriff’s Office statement Tuesday evening. “By Monday evening when the couple had not yet returned the urgency increased.”

Volunteers from Mountain Rescue Aspen began searching for Marcil and Brightwell at 7:55 a.m. Tuesday, according to the statement.

A post Tuesday morning by MRA on the site said they were last seen at about 11:30 a.m. Sunday around 13,900 feet on their way to the summit. Witnesses interviewed by the Sheriff’s Office said they’d seen Brightwell and Marcil near the Knife Edge, a 100-foot-long obstacle very close to the summit, Steindler said.

“Part of the problem was we could never find anyone who saw them on the descent,” he said.

The statement said they may have chose to descend by a different route.

Around 12:50 p.m. Tuesday, a CareFlight helicopter based in Rifle and a National Guard Black Hawk helicopter based in Gypsum were deployed to search, according to the statement. The National Guard helicopter spotted the bodies an hour and a half later, and MRA volunteers were able to reach the couple and confirm they were dead, the release states.

“We have no idea what happened,” Steindler said.

On Aug. 6, 35-year-old Jeremy Shull of Parker fell from the east side of the ridge between K2 and the Knife Edge. On July 15, Jack Lord, 25, also from Parker died when a boulder he was holding gave way on the ridge between Capitol and Mt. Daly. Since 2003, eight people have died climbing Capitol Peak.

Hank Carter, an advertising representative at The Aspen Times, knew Marcil and Brightwell before they began dating.

“They were fully in love and talking about how they were going to get married,” Carter said Tuesday.

Addie Godfrey became friends with Brightwell in Aspen and said she “appreciated every ray of sunshine, every snowflake that fell and every breath she took. She knew the power of a smile, the strength of a hug and the indescribable meaning of friendship.”

According to Marcil’s Facebook page, he moved to Aspen in November 2016. Parker Condit, a close friend of Marcil’s, said that as soon as the couple began dating they were nearly always together.

“They got serious pretty quickly,” he said.

Dee Humphrey, a Denver resident, said she grew up with Marcil in Vero Beach, Florida, and hung out with Marcil and Brightwell a few weeks ago when they came to her house-warming party.

“From what Ryan told me, they were really in love,” she said. “He’s never liked a girl like that before since I’ve known him, so we were really happy for him.”

Humphrey said the couple had recently moved in together in Aspen.

“They moved really, really quickly,” she said. “They were happy and in love.”

Marcil was the older brother of Humphrey’s best friend and he looked out for her and her friends and took them out on boats in Florida when she was growing up, she said.

He was always in good shape and athletic, and mainly was into water sports, Humphrey said. She said Marcil’s sister told her Tuesday that hiking and climbing in the Colorado mountains was a new hobby for her brother.

“It was just in the last few months,” she said.

Marcil, who worked this past winter at Surefoot in Aspen, took part in Aspen Strong’s annual hiking event Saturday on Smuggler Mountain before heading out to climb Capitol Peak, said Condit, who also serves on the group’s board. Marcil played tennis at Bucknell University in Pennsylvania and used to work in finance in New York City, Condit said.

“He was a people person,” Condit said. “He was charming, funny, smart.”

Brightwell was from Cincinnati, according to her Facebook page.

“She was awesome,” Carter said. “She was always smiling. She was really energetic and outgoing. She could make friends with a doorknob.”

Support Local Journalism

Support Local Journalism

Readers around Craig and Moffat County make the Craig Press’ work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Each donation will be used exclusively for the development and creation of increased news coverage.