Students aren't variables in an equation



Lance Scranton

I spoke with a recent graduate a couple of weeks ago who is in college and working toward a degree.

I asked him how things were going and the response was not surprising: “Coach, I had a rough first semester, but I got it together and am doing just fine now. But I sure miss high school.”

I asked why, and he said, “You guys cared about us even though we didn’t always treat you right. You guys really helped us get stuff done so we could pass.”

I described how little concern his college professors had for him getting to class on time or turning in assignments and he exclaimed, “Right, Coach, they just lecture and we get our stuff done or we fail. They don’t even care if you show up to class.”

I asked if there is anything we could have done differently to better prepare him for life after high school.

“I don’t think so because I just wasn’t mature enough yet and you guys kinda’ spoiled us so I had to learn some hard lessons,” he said.

This isn’t the first conversation of this type I have had with graduates about their adjustment to life after high school.

As high school teachers try to better prepare our students for their future, we are faced with some pretty tough obstacles to overcome:

We test and test and then plot our children on spreadsheets so we can classify them as “proficient,” or “still-emerging.”

Students are increasingly described as “widgets,” “data-points,” or “outcomes.” These are terms more likened to the business world serving a customer than schools serving children.

Teachers are expected to “facilitate instruction” to a minimum level of “proficiency” and are evaluated by “artifacts,” which are analyzed to prove students are learning.

This professional language is the result of a hyper-computerized culture that collects information and breaks it down into many different categories. Try as I might, I just can’t bring myself to explain to a parent that, “We have identified this particular outcome as evidence of academic ability outside the normal indicators measurable in the gifted and talented cohort.”

The problem with this type of professional language is that it describes in the absence of any personality. It’s as though the statement could be describing anyone or anything.

I just tell parents their kid is really smart and might need some more challenging work.

When I go to parent-teacher conferences I ask two questions: Are my sons being respectful in class and do they listen?

These two attributes trump all the data they show me each year because I know that when they leave the protection of our public schools, how my kids approach life will be discernably more important than which cohort they find themselves in each year

I guess I’m likely not “proficient in establishing rigorous identifiers for academic achievement.”

But, I am passionate about teaching your child and ecstatic when a former student goes on to be a successful, productive citizen.

Click here to have the print version of the Craig Daily Press delivered to your home.


serenity9700 4 years, 12 months ago

Your story makes me wonder, Mr. Scranton, if our students aren't being challenged enough to prepare them for life after high school.

When my daughter was in elementary school I was glad she had teachers who assigned homework. I thought that was good preparation for the workload she would get in secondary school. Little did I realize that "homework" would slowly become non-existent as she went through CMS and into MCHS.

As my younger son has gone through elementary, there has been no homework in sight. What does this mean? That the teaching is more efficient?

My daughter does not care about her grades. A sign of her age, sure, but when I look at the campus portal and see in one semester of algebra the assignments listed equal MAYBE one month's worth of the work I had to do when I was that age I have to wonder what there is for her to care about.

What pride is there in a job well done when the job was too easy? Is that what it means when you say "every student will graduate?" The story of your former student could be quite it just too easy at MCHS?


Requires free registration

Posting comments requires a free account and verification.