Craig and Steamboat residents respond to Moffat County's health rankings
On April 2 County Health Rankings & Roadmaps, a report compiled by the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, rated Moffat County among the unhealthiest in the state. Craig and Steamboat residents respond to the report and explain why exercise is an important part of their lives.
By the numbers ...
2012 County Health Rankings & Roadmaps report out of 59 Colorado counties:
(Moffat County/Routt County)
• Mortality: 47/11
• Morbidity: 51/9
• Health behaviors: 59/5
• Clinical care: 53/6
• Social, economic factors: 33/11
• Physical environment: 11/4
• Overall: 50/9
— Information compiled by the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment.
According to a report by County Health Rankings & Roadmaps, Moffat County residents are among the unhealthiest in the state.
The report data was compiled by the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, said Lisa Brown, chief executive officer of the Northwest Colorado Visiting Nurse Association.
The report ranks counties in categories such as mortality, morbidity, health behaviors, clinical care, social and economic factors, and physical environment.
Overall, Moffat County ranks 50th out of Colorado’s 59 counties. By contrast, neighboring Routt County ranked ninth overall.
Brown presented the data to the Moffat County Commission earlier this month and cited concerns with Moffat County’s ranking regarding health behaviors.
The health behaviors category includes smoking, obesity, physical inactivity and drinking. Moffat County ranked 59th in the category, or last among counties in the state. Routt County ranked fifth.
“Individual behaviors like smoking, drinking and obesity have not improved in Moffat County in a long time,” Brown said. “There is no doubt we have a high rate of substance abuse throughout the region.”
According to the report, 26 percent of Moffat County residents smoke, or 12- and 8-percent higher than national and state averages, respectively.
Thirty percent of residents are considered excessive drinkers, 22- and 12-percent higher than national and state averages.
Additionally, more than 25 percent of Moffat County residents are considered physically inactive, according to the data.
The health behaviors of Routt County residents were considerably lower in every respect except one.
According to data, 35 percent of Routt County residents are considered excessive drinkers.
“I think a resort-based economy, which is more prevalent in Routt, and subsequent seasonal employment opportunities attracts a certain type of person to our region,” Brown said.
Another area Moffat County lags behind the rest of the state is in clinical care.
The clinical care portion of the report includes the number of residents not covered by health insurance, a ratio of available primary care doctors compared to Moffat County’s population, the number of preventable hospital stays, and access to diabetic and mammography screenings.
Moffat County ranks 53rd in the clinical care category. Routt County ranks sixth.
By far the most discouraging statistic, Brown said, is the number of uninsured residents in Moffat County.
According to County Health Rankings & Roadmaps, 20 percent of Moffat County residents do not have health insurance.
Brown said she believes that statistic is inaccurate and estimates the number of uninsured residents in Moffat County is closer to 30 percent.
If she is correct, the number of uninsured Moffat County residents would be nearly three times higher than the national average and double that of Routt County.
Jennifer Riley, chief of organizational excellence at The Memorial Hospital in Craig, believes there is a connection between the county’s overall health ranking and the rate of uninsured residents.
“Moffat County is in a really rural area and it is hard because sometimes you do have to go elsewhere to get the care you need,” Riley said. “Maybe you can’t afford it, so you don’t do it and it (a health problem) compounds itself.”
When the report was released, Riley said TMH staffers began conversations about what the hospital’s role should be.
TMH is currently in the process of constructing an informational campaign on the importance of preventative care.
“I don’t think there is anybody who doesn’t understand the impact smoking has on your overall health,” Riley said. “If you can’t see a doctor it just gets worse, which has an impact on all of us.”
That impact is primarily financial, Brown said.
Although many uninsured people do not take proactive steps in their own health, when they believe they have reached a critical point in their own well-being, they not only believe they are entitled to quality healthcare, they demand it, Brown said.
“Uninsured people have a large impact on the community,” Riley added. “TMH and the VNA see a lot of uninsured people who qualify for ‘charity’ or discounted care. It costs the same to provide those services to someone who has health insurance as it does to those who don’t have health insurance.
“We all pay the price for people who don’t want to be proactive in their health.”
If uninsured, unhealthy people are driving up the cost of healthcare for the masses, what role, if any, should government play in the well-being of residents? It’s a question the county commission considered during Brown’s presentation.
“It’s a contentious issue,” commissioner Tom Gray said. “We all want people to lead healthier lives, but at what cost? How do we justify taking away a person’s right to make their own decisions?”
Brown said she is a staunch supporter of an individual’s right to make their own life choices, but pointed to Moffat County’s high rankings regarding mortality and morbidity.
The mortality classification ranks counties on just one factor — premature death rate.
Moffat County ranks 47th in this category, where Routt County ranks 11th.
“I think it’s time for me to get out of town,” Gray said.
Brown said Moffat County’s high premature death rate has nothing to do with physical surroundings.
“This isn’t saying you run the risk of dying early simply because you live here,” Brown said. “And it’s not saying you have a better chance of living longer by moving 40 miles down the road.”
Instead, she said Moffat County’s high rate of premature death might factor into how residents view their own morbidity.
Morbidity data, Brown said, is compiled by simply calling residents and “asking them how they feel.”
According to County Health Rankings & Roadmaps, 23 percent of Moffat County residents believe they are in poor to fair health.
Additionally, Moffat County residents report experiencing 4.5 poor physical health days and 3.7 poor mental health days per month.
Moffat County ranks 51st in morbidity. Routt County ranks ninth.
Brown said factors like poor health behavior, a high rate of uninsured residents and high rate of substance abuse plays a direct role in how people feel about themselves, both physically and mentally.
Though she does not expect local government to take specific action immediately, Brown cited examples of how legislation has contributed to positive changes in health behavior.
“As to the role government can play in public health, large changes do tend to come through laws and policies that change behavior,” Brown said. “Seat belt legislation and enforcement is a classic example.”
Jim Gregoire, who operates Trapper Fitness Center in Craig with his wife, Barb, believes he knows the prescription for improving not only Moffat County’s physical health, but also its mental health — exercise.
“Exercise is the second-leading prescription for depression in the United States,” Gregoire said. “Exercise, coupled with traditional medication, is prescribed in more than 70 percent of all depression cases.”
Gregoire studied exercise science at the University of Wyoming and earned a master’s in 1997.
He wrote his thesis on the connection between exercise and the production of positive neurochemicals in the brain.
“There’s a lot we know about the human body, but we’re still in an infancy of understanding neurochemicals in the brain,” Gregoire said. “But, what exercise scientists have found is that rhythmatic exercises like walking, running, cross-country skiing, biking and dancing help promote the secretion of positive neurochemicals.
“Exercise is a great prescription for a lot of things, especially pathological conditions like depression.”
Click here to have the print version of the Craig Daily Press delivered to your home.